#59 Count the rounds, not the rejections

You'd never walk into a WBR and say "the numbers feel bad."

But that's how most senior searches get reviewed. A few months of applications, some rejections, a couple of ghostings, and one conclusion: it's not working.

Two clients this year had almost the same arc. Both kept reaching the hiring manager round. Both kept going out right there. And both had started reading it as proof that something was wrong with them.

Nothing was. They had the skills to do the job. Hiring manager after hiring manager had looked at them and wanted the conversation. The profile was doing its job, and the targeting was close. Everything worked right up to one room.

What was happening in that room was different for each of them.

The first was moving industries. Their answers were strong, but every story was set in a world the hiring manager didn't know, so the manager spent the conversation trying to picture them in theirs. Once we rebuilt the stories around how they work, the parts that travel to any industry, the manager could see the fit without doing the translating.

The second had the scope and wasn't saying it. The size of the team, the budget, how many orgs depended on the thing they ran. Those are the signals a hiring manager uses to place your level, and without them the work came across a size smaller than it was. They were getting read a level down.

We knew the problem was solved where they started surviving longer in the process.

Both landed well and are happily chugging along in their new roles.

Where you keep stopping tells you what to fix. How often you stop mostly tells you how many applications you've sent.

Both of those problems start in the same place. Inside Amazon, you just knew roughly what someone at your level owned, and moving between businesses didn't mean starting from zero. Nobody needed you to spell out your scope or translate your context.

Outside, the hiring manager round is usually the first place someone actually tests whether your experience fits their world, at the level they need. And without feedback it's easy to invent stories about why you're not moving forward.

One thing to try this week: List your last ten processes and write down the round each one ended. No commentary, no "but that one was a bad fit." Just the stage. Then look for the round that shows up most. From there it's an opportunity to identify what's actually breaking down or not being communicated well.

Previous
Previous

#60 Are your interview stories a level behind?

Next
Next

#58 Start with what you've already built